Turkey's Geopolitical Ambitions and Pakistan's Strategic Role:
Opportunities, Opposition, and Future Outlook
Turkey’s geopolitical ambitions aim to reassert its
historical influence as a Eurasian power, bridging Europe, Asia, and the Middle
East. Positioned at the crossroads of civilizations, Turkey seeks regional
hegemony, energy and trade dominance, and leadership in the Muslim world while
maintaining strategic autonomy. Pakistan is a vital partner in these goals,
offering Turkey a foothold in South Asia, a defense market, and a gateway to
Central Asia and the Indian Ocean Region (IOR). However, Turkey faces opposition
from several nations, including the United States, which complicates its
aspirations. This note examines Turkey’s ambitions, Pakistan’s role, NATO
compatibility, defense investments in Pakistan, geopolitical competitors,
opposing countries, and potential developments by 2030, supported by expert
insights and inferences.
Abstract Turkey’s geopolitical ambitions
aim to reassert its role as a Eurasian power, leveraging its strategic
location to dominate trade, energy, and regional influence while championing
Muslim causes. Pakistan is a critical partner, offering Turkey a defense market,
a counterweight to India, and access to Central Asia and the Indian Ocean
Region. This partnership, rooted in shared Islamic identity, includes
significant Turkish defense investments, such as MILGEM corvettes and drones,
targeting $5 billion in bilateral trade by 2025. However, Turkey’s NATO
membership creates tensions, balancing Western alliances with autonomous
policies. Opposition from the United States, India, Greece, Cyprus, Saudi
Arabia, and France—through sanctions, alliances, and diplomacy—challenges
Turkey’s plans. By 2030, Turkey-Pakistan ties could deepen via joint projects
like the KAAN fighter jet, though economic constraints and geopolitical
rivalries pose risks. This note examines Turkey’s ambitions, Pakistan’s role,
NATO compatibility, defense cooperation, competitors, opposition strategies,
and future prospects, drawing on expert insights. It infers that while the
Turkey-Pakistan axis strengthens both nations, navigating external pressures
and internal challenges will determine its success, potentially reshaping
Eurasian geopolitics |
(A nationalist
Turkish television station with close ties to President Recep Tayyip ErdoÄźan
has dug up a 12-year-old map that projects Turkey’s sphere of influence in 2050
as stretching from southeastern Europe on the northern coast of the
Mediterranean and Libya on its southern shore across North Africa, the Gulf,
and the Levant into the Caucasus and Central Asia.)
Turkey’s Geopolitical Ambitions
Turkey’s foreign policy, often termed “neo-Ottoman” or
“multi-vector,” leverages its strategic geography and historical legacy to
project power. Key objectives include:
- Regional
Hegemony: Turkey seeks influence in the Black Sea, Middle East, and
Central Asia, controlling key routes like the Bosphorus. “Turkey’s unique
position shapes its regional ambitions,” says Arik Burakovsky, assistant
director at The Fletcher School.
- Energy
and Trade Hub: Turkey aims to connect Europe with Asia via the Middle
Corridor. “Turkey sees Ukraine’s war as a chance to diversify energy
routes,” notes Hudson Institute.
- Muslim
World Leadership: Turkey champions causes like Palestine and Kashmir.
“ErdoÄźan’s Pakistan visits aim to align OIC strategies,” says Muhammed
Bilal Iftekhar Khan, a Lahore-based analyst.
- Strategic
Autonomy: Turkey pursues a “360-degree” policy to balance East and
West. “Ankara aspires to be a global power center,” observes Carnegie
Endowment.
- Military
Modernization: Turkey’s defense industry, notably drones, supports
power projection. “Turkey excels in drone exports,” says Haluk Bayraktar,
Baykar CEO.
Pakistan’s Role in Turkey’s Ambitions
Pakistan is a cornerstone of Turkey’s South Asian strategy,
driven by shared Islamic identity and historical ties from the Khilafat
Movement. Pakistan’s roles include:
- Defense
Partnership: Pakistan is a key buyer of Turkish arms and a
co-production partner. “Turkey aids Pakistan’s naval modernization,” says
Khan. Projects include corvettes and drones.
- Geopolitical
Counterweight: Pakistan counters India’s influence in the Gulf and
IOR. “Turkey consistently backs Pakistan on Kashmir,” notes The Indian
Express.
- Central
Asia and Afghanistan Access: Pakistan’s proximity facilitates Turkey’s
Middle Corridor and Afghan influence. “Ankara relies on Pakistan’s Taliban
ties,” says The European Institute.
- Economic
Ties: Bilateral trade targets $5 billion by 2025. “ErdoÄźan emphasized
connectivity via rail and road,” reports The Media Line.
- Soft
Power: Pakistan amplifies Turkey’s Muslim leadership. “The Islamabad
Declaration combats Islamophobia,” notes The European Institute.
NATO Membership and Compatibility
Turkey’s 1952 NATO membership anchors it to the West but
creates tensions with its autonomous ambitions:
- Balancing
Act: Turkey supports NATO’s Ukraine stance but avoids Russian
sanctions. “Engagement with Moscow isn’t approval,” says İbrahim Kalın,
Turkish intelligence chief.
- NATO
Tensions: The S-400 purchase and Sweden’s accession delays strained
ties. “Turkey’s actions raised NATO security concerns,” notes Institute
for Global Affairs.
- Pakistan
Concerns: Turkey’s Pakistan ties worry NATO allies. “A Turkey-Pakistan
conflict with India wouldn’t trigger Article 5,” argues Indian Defence
Review.
- Strategic
Leverage: NATO enhances Turkey’s global clout. “Turkey’s Ukraine role
strengthens its NATO position,” says Hudson Institute.
Turkey uses NATO for security and technology while pursuing
Pakistan ties, creating a delicate balance. “Turkey’s NATO role complicates its
geopolitics,” says IEMed.
Turkey’s Defense Investments in Pakistan
Turkey is Pakistan’s second-largest arms supplier after
China, with significant investments:
- Naval
Projects:
- MILGEM
Corvettes: A $1.5 billion deal for four corvettes. “MILGEM is
Turkey’s largest military export,” notes Wikipedia.
- Submarine
Upgrades: A $350 million contract upgraded three Agosta 90-B
submarines. “ASELSAN and HAVELSAN technologies were key,” says IDSA.
- Drones
and Missiles:
- Bayraktar
TB2 Drones: Delivered in 2022. “Pakistan bought Kemankes missiles,”
reports The Indian Express.
- Asisguard
Songar Drones: Used in 2025 India attacks. “Songar drones were
confirmed,” says IAS Gyan.
- Helicopters
and Pods:
- T129
ATAK Helicopters: A $1.5 billion deal stalled by U.S. sanctions.
“Pakistan may turn to China,” says Kalın.
- ASELPOD
Targeting Pods: A $25 million deal for 16 pods.
- Joint
Ventures:
- Plans
for a KAAN fighter jet factory. “Pakistan eyes KAAN fighters,” reports
Eurasian Times.
- TAI
and Havelsan collaborate on tech projects. “TAI works with Pakistan,”
says The Nation.
- Training:
- 1,500
Pakistani officers trained in Turkey. Exercises like Turgutreis enhance
interoperability. “Turgutreis spans the Indian Ocean,” notes IDSA.
Turkey’s $9 billion defense exports in 2023 included
significant Pakistan deals, strengthening both nations’ militaries and
countering India.
Geopolitical Competitors
Turkey faces competition from:
- Russia:
Turkey checks Russian Black Sea ambitions but maintains trade. “Turkey
opposes Russian expansion,” says Hudson Institute.
- China:
Turkey engages China but competes in Central Asia. “Turkey rejected
Chinese missiles, irking Beijing,” notes Carnegie.
- Saudi
Arabia/UAE: Turkey vies for Muslim leadership. “Turkey’s Pakistan ties
counter Gulf influence,” says IDSA.
- India:
India’s Gulf and Greek ties oppose Turkey. “India backs Cyprus against
Turkey,” says Rau’s IAS.
- Iran:
Syria and Azerbaijan tensions strain ties. “Turkey-Iran relations are
fragile,” says FPRI.
Countries Opposing Turkey’s Ambitions and Their Actions
Several nations oppose Turkey’s ambitions, using diplomatic,
economic, and military measures:
- United
States:
- Actions:
The U.S. imposed CAATSA sanctions over S-400 purchases, halting F-35
deliveries. “Sanctions limited Turkey’s defense capabilities,” says
Atlantic Council. The U.S. also restricts engine exports for Pakistan’s
T129 helicopters.
- Motives:
Concerns over Turkey’s Russia ties and NATO reliability. “Turkey’s
autonomy worries Washington,” notes FPRI.
- Impact:
Sanctions strain Turkey’s defense industry, affecting Pakistan deals.
- India:
- Actions:
India strengthens ties with Greece, Cyprus, and Gulf states to counter
Turkey-Pakistan. “India’s Greece partnership targets Turkey,” says Rau’s
IAS. India also lobbies against Turkey’s Kashmir stance in the OIC.
- Motives:
To neutralize Turkey’s support for Pakistan. “India sees Turkey as a
Pakistan enabler,” notes The Indian Express.
- Impact:
India’s diplomacy isolates Turkey in South Asia.
- Greece
and Cyprus:
- Actions:
Greece conducts joint exercises with India and the UAE, opposing Turkey’s
Mediterranean claims. Cyprus seeks EU sanctions over maritime disputes.
“Greece-Cyprus align against Turkey,” says IEMed.
- Motives:
Territorial disputes and Turkey’s Libya support. “Turkey’s Mediterranean
moves alarm Greece,” notes Carnegie.
- Impact:
EU pressure limits Turkey’s regional maneuvers.
- Saudi
Arabia and UAE:
- Actions:
Both nations back India and fund anti-Turkey lobbies. “Saudi-UAE tilt
toward India counters Turkey,” says IDSA. They also reduce Turkey’s OIC
influence.
- Motives:
Rivalry for Muslim leadership. “Turkey’s Qatar-Pakistan axis irks
Riyadh,” notes Hudson Institute.
- Impact:
Gulf funding strengthens Turkey’s rivals.
- France:
- Actions:
France supports Greece and Cyprus in Mediterranean disputes and leads EU
criticism of Turkey. “France-Turkey tensions are acute,” says The
European Institute.
- Motives:
Turkey’s Libya and Syria policies. “France opposes Turkey’s regional
assertiveness,” notes IEMed.
- Impact:
EU sanctions discussions constrain Turkey.
These nations use sanctions, alliances, and diplomacy to
curb Turkey’s influence, impacting its Pakistan ties and regional plans.
Possible Developments by 2030
By 2030, Turkey’s ambitions and Pakistan’s role could evolve
based on current trends:
- Strengthened
Turkey-Pakistan Axis:
- Joint
KAAN production could materialize, boosting both nations’ defense
industries. “KAAN could transform Pakistan’s air force,” says Eurasian
Times.
- Trade
may hit $5 billion, with rail connectivity enhancing the Middle Corridor.
“Connectivity is key,” notes The Media Line.
- Risk:
U.S. sanctions or India’s counter-moves could delay projects.
- NATO
Dynamics:
- Turkey
may deepen NATO engagement to counter sanctions, possibly moderating
Pakistan ties. “Turkey needs NATO for leverage,” says Hudson Institute.
- Risk:
Persistent S-400 issues could further strain U.S.-Turkey ties.
- Regional
Shifts:
- Turkey
may gain Afghan influence via Pakistan, but Iran’s opposition could
complicate this. “Iran dislikes Turkey’s Afghan role,” says FPRI.
- India’s
Gulf ties may limit Turkey’s IOR influence. “India’s Gulf strategy is
robust,” notes Rau’s IAS.
- Economic
Challenges:
- Turkey’s
inflation and reconstruction costs may slow investments in Pakistan.
“Economic woes limit Turkey’s reach,” says FPRI.
- Opportunity:
Chinese BRI investments could complement Turkey-Pakistan projects.
- Muslim
World Leadership:
- Turkey
may solidify its OIC role with Pakistan’s support, but Saudi-UAE
opposition will persist. “Turkey’s leadership bid faces Gulf hurdles,”
says IDSA.
- Opportunity:
Joint initiatives like the Islamabad Declaration could gain traction.
Turkey and Pakistan are likely to deepen ties, but
opposition from the U.S., India, and others will require careful navigation.
Technological advancements and economic recovery could bolster their
partnership.
Inferences
- Mutual
Benefits: Turkey-Pakistan ties enhance Turkey’s South Asian influence
and Pakistan’s military strength, countering India and Gulf rivals.
- NATO
Constraints: Turkey’s NATO role provides security but limits its
autonomy, especially with Pakistan, amid U.S. and EU scrutiny.
- Opposition
Challenges: U.S. sanctions, India’s alliances, and Gulf rivalry
threaten Turkey’s plans, requiring diplomatic agility.
- Economic
Limits: Turkey’s domestic issues may hinder ambitious projects, but
Pakistan’s strategic value ensures sustained engagement.
- Future
Potential: By 2030, joint defense and trade initiatives could make
Turkey-Pakistan a key Eurasian bloc, if they overcome external pressures.
Conclusion
Turkey’s ambitions to become a Eurasian power hinge on
strategic partnerships like Pakistan, which offers defense markets,
geopolitical alignment, and Muslim world influence. Despite NATO tensions and
opposition from the U.S., India, Greece, Cyprus, Gulf states, and France,
Turkey leverages its defense industry and pragmatic diplomacy to advance its
goals. By 2030, Turkey-Pakistan ties could deepen through joint production and
trade, though economic and geopolitical hurdles remain. Balancing autonomy with
alliances will define Turkey’s success.
References
- Foreign
Policy Research Institute, “Turkey’s Geopolitical Strategy,” 2024.
- Wikipedia,
“Pakistan–Turkey Relations,” 2025.
- IDSA,
“Turkiye–Pakistan Defence Cooperation,” 2024.
- The
European Institute, “Asia’s Geopolitical Formations,” 2021.
- Carnegie
Endowment, “TĂĽrkiye’s World Order Role,” 2023.
- IEMed,
“Turkey’s Geopolitical Role,” 2023.
- Hudson
Institute, “Turkey in the Russia-Ukraine War,” 2025.
- The
Indian Express, “Pakistan-Turkey Nexus,” 2025.
- Atlantic
Council, “Turkey’s Disruptive Technologies,” 2024.
- Indian
Defence Review, “Turkey in Pakistan,” 2025.
- The
Nation, “Pak-Turk Relations,” 2025.
- The
Media Line, “Pakistan-Turkey Ties,” 2025.
- Institute
for Global Affairs, “Turkey’s Foreign Policy,” 2023.
- CAPS
India, “Pakistan-Turkiye Relations,” 2025.
- The
Fletcher School, “Turkey’s Global Role,” 2023.
- Eurasian
Times, “Pakistan’s KAAN Interest,” 2025.
Appendix: The KAAN Project
Introduction
The KAAN Project, spearheaded by Turkish Aerospace
Industries (TAI), is Turkey’s flagship initiative to develop its first
indigenous fifth-generation fighter jet, officially named the TAI TF Kaan
(formerly TF-X). Launched in 2011, the project aims to bolster Turkey’s air
superiority, reduce dependence on foreign military technology, and position
Turkey as a global defense exporter. The KAAN is designed to replace Turkey’s
aging F-16 fleet and compete with advanced fighters like the U.S. F-35 and
Russia’s Su-57. With Pakistan as a key partner, the project enhances the
Turkey-Pakistan strategic axis, aligning with Turkey’s broader geopolitical
ambitions to assert influence in Eurasia and South Asia.
Objectives and Strategic Importance
The KAAN Project is a cornerstone of Turkey’s defense
modernization and strategic autonomy:
- Self-Reliance:
Over 80% of components are indigenously developed, reducing reliance on
foreign suppliers. “KAAN is Turkey’s bid for defense independence,” says
TAI CEO Temel Kotil.
- Air
Superiority: The jet is designed for multi-role missions, including
air-to-air combat, ground attack, and electronic warfare.
- Export
Potential: Turkey aims to market KAAN to allies like Pakistan,
Azerbaijan, and Qatar. “KAAN could reshape regional air power,” notes
Defense News.
- Geopolitical
Leverage: The project strengthens Turkey’s NATO role while supporting
non-Western partnerships, particularly with Pakistan.
Technical Specifications
The TAI TF Kaan is a twin-engine, stealth-capable fighter
with advanced technology:
- Stealth:
Low-observable design with radar-absorbing materials and internal weapon
bays. “KAAN’s stealth rivals Western fighters,” says an Atlantic Council
report.
- Avionics:
Active Electronically Scanned Array (AESA) radar, AI-based flight systems,
and networked warfare capabilities.
- Engines:
Currently uses General Electric F110 engines, with TRMotor developing
indigenous engines by 2030. “Engine indigenization is critical,” notes
IDSA.
- Performance:
Maximum speed of Mach 2, service ceiling of 55,000 feet, and a combat
range of 1,100 miles.
- Weapons:
Supports air-to-air missiles (e.g., Meteor), air-to-ground munitions, and
Turkey’s SOM cruise missiles.
- Dimensions:
Length of 21 meters, wingspan of 14 meters, and a maximum takeoff weight
of 60,000 pounds.
Development Timeline
- 2011:
Project announced under Turkey’s National Combat Aircraft Program.
- 2016:
TAI partnered with BAE Systems for technical support.
- 2023:
Prototype unveiled; Pakistan signed an MoU for co-production.
- February
2024: First flight completed successfully.
- 2026–2028:
Planned serial production.
- 2029–2030:
Targeted operational deployment in Turkish and potentially Pakistani air
forces.
Cost and Funding
- Unit
Cost: Estimated at $100 million per aircraft, competitive with the
F-35’s $110 million.
- Program
Cost: Approximately $14 billion, covering R&D, production, and
testing.
- Challenges:
Turkey’s economic issues, including inflation and post-2023 earthquake
recovery, strain funding. “Economic woes challenge KAAN’s budget,” says
FPRI.
- Mitigation:
Partnerships with Pakistan and potential Gulf investors may offset costs.
Pakistan’s Role
Pakistan is a strategic partner, enhancing the project’s
geopolitical and economic viability:
- Co-Production:
A 2023 MoU outlines joint production, with Pakistan contributing to
subsystems like avionics and composites. “Pakistan eyes a KAAN factory,”
reports Eurasian Times.
- Acquisition:
Pakistan plans to acquire 30–50 KAAN jets to counter India’s Rafale and
AMCA programs. “KAAN could transform Pakistan’s air force,” says IDSA.
- Training
and Integration: Pakistani pilots are training with Turkish forces,
and joint exercises like Turgutreis test interoperability.
- Strategic
Alignment: The project strengthens Turkey’s support for Pakistan on
Kashmir and counters India’s regional influence. “KAAN deepens the
Turkey-Pakistan nexus,” notes The Indian Express.
Geopolitical Implications
The KAAN Project aligns with Turkey’s ambitions to project
power and lead the Muslim world:
- NATO
Dynamics: KAAN enhances Turkey’s NATO contributions but faces U.S.
sanctions over engine exports and S-400 issues. “U.S. restrictions limit
KAAN’s progress,” says Atlantic Council.
- South
Asia: Pakistan’s involvement counters India’s air superiority,
escalating regional tensions. “India views KAAN as a threat,” says Rau’s
IAS.
- Muslim
World: Successful exports to Pakistan and others could solidify
Turkey’s defense leadership. “KAAN is a symbol of Turkey’s ambitions,”
notes Hudson Institute.
- Opposition:
The U.S., India, and Gulf states (Saudi Arabia, UAE) oppose the project
through sanctions, rival alliances, and lobbying. “India’s Greek ties
target Turkey’s plans,” says IEMed.
Challenges and Risks
- Engine
Development: Dependence on U.S. engines delays full indigenization.
“Engine tech is a bottleneck,” says Defense News.
- Sanctions:
U.S. CAATSA sanctions and export controls hinder progress, especially for
Pakistan’s acquisitions.
- Economic
Constraints: Turkey’s inflation (over 50% in 2024) and reconstruction
costs limit funding.
- Technical
Hurdles: Developing stealth and AI systems requires expertise Turkey
is still building.
- Geopolitical
Pushback: India’s partnerships with Greece, Cyprus, and the Gulf,
alongside U.S. and French opposition, could restrict exports and
diplomatic support.
Future Outlook (By 2030)
- Operational
Success: KAAN is likely to enter service by 2030, with 50–100 units
for Turkey and 30–50 for Pakistan, assuming funding and technical
milestones are met.
- Export
Growth: Azerbaijan, Qatar, and Malaysia may join as buyers, boosting
Turkey’s $9 billion defense export market.
- Regional
Impact: KAAN could shift South Asian air power dynamics, strengthening
Pakistan against India but escalating tensions.
- Risk
Mitigation: Turkey may seek Chinese or European engine partnerships if
U.S. restrictions persist. “Turkey explores engine alternatives,” notes
Carnegie Endowment.
- Geopolitical
Leverage: A successful KAAN could enhance Turkey’s NATO bargaining
power and Muslim world influence, provided it navigates opposition.
Conclusion
The KAAN Project is a transformative endeavor for Turkey’s
defense industry and geopolitical strategy, symbolizing its quest for autonomy
and regional dominance. With Pakistan’s partnership, KAAN strengthens the
Turkey-Pakistan axis, counters India, and supports Turkey’s Middle Corridor and
Muslim leadership goals. Despite economic, technical, and geopolitical
challenges, the project’s success by 2030 could redefine Eurasian and South
Asian security dynamics, positioning Turkey as a global defense player.
References
- Defense
News, “Turkey’s TF-X Progress,” 2024.
- Eurasian
Times, “Pakistan’s KAAN Interest,” 2025.
- IDSA,
“Turkiye–Pakistan Defence Cooperation,” 2024.
- Atlantic
Council, “Turkey’s Defense Challenges,” 2024.
- Foreign
Policy Research Institute, “Turkey’s Geopolitical Strategy,” 2024.
- Hudson
Institute, “Turkey’s Role in Global Defense,” 2025.
- The
Indian Express, “Pakistan-Turkey Nexus,” 2025.
- Rau’s
IAS, “Pakistan-Turkey and India,” 2025.
- IEMed,
“Turkey’s Geopolitical Role,” 2023.
- Carnegie
Endowment, “TĂĽrkiye’s World Order Role,” 2023.
Comments
Post a Comment